| Date | Title | Time | Location | Result |
| Mar. 12, 2012 | vs. Franklin & Marshall (Game 1) | 3:00 PM | Lake Myrtle Park (Auburndale, Fla.) | Loss, 6-10 |
| Mar. 12, 2012 | vs. Franklin & Marshall (Game 2) | 5:30 PM | Lake Myrtle Park (Auburndale, Fla.) | Loss, 2-10 |
| Mar. 13, 2012 | vs. Mass. College of Liberal Arts (Game 1) | 9:30 AM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Loss, 3-4 |
| Mar. 13, 2012 | vs. Mass. College of Liberal Arts (Game 2) | 12:00 PM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Win, 7-3 |
| Mar. 14, 2012 | vs. Lesley | 4:00 PM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Win, 10-3 |
| Mar. 16, 2012 | vs. Mount Saint Vincent | 11:30 AM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Loss, 5-9 |
| Mar. 16, 2012 | vs. Washington (Md.) | 3:30 PM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Loss, 10-11 |
| Mar. 17, 2012 | vs. Drew | 4:00 PM | Pat Thomas Stadium (Leesburg, Fla.) | Loss, 3-7 |
| Mar. 18, 2012 | vs. Washington & Jefferson (Game 1) | 12:00 PM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Loss, 1-8 |
| Mar. 18, 2012 | vs. Washington & Jefferson (Game 2) | 2:30 PM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Loss, 4-11 |
| Mar. 20, 2012 | vs. Union (Game 1) | 10:00 AM | Lake Myrtle Park (Auburndale, Fla.) | Loss, 0-13 |
| Mar. 20, 2012 | vs. Union (Game 2) | 12:30 PM | Lake Myrtle Park (Auburndale, Fla.) | Win, 2-0 |
| Mar. 21, 2012 | vs. Trinity (Game 1) | 12:00 PM | Lake Myrtle Park (Auburndale, Fla.) | Loss, 0-9 |
| Mar. 21, 2012 | vs. Trinity (Game 2) | 2:30 PM | Lake Myrtle Park (Auburndale, Fla.) | Loss, 0-14 |
| Mar. 22, 2012 | vs. Sewanee | 4:00 PM | Chain of Lakes Park (Winter Haven, Fla.) | Loss, 5-10 |
| Mar. 30, 2012 | at Amherst¹ | 3:30 PM | Amherst, Mass. | Loss, 1-13 |
| Mar. 31, 2012 | at Amherst (Game 1)¹ | 12:00 PM | Amherst, Mass. | Loss, 0-8 |
| Mar. 31, 2012 | at Amherst (Game 2)¹ | 2:30 PM | Amherst, Mass. | Loss, 2-6 |
| Apr. 7, 2012 | SUNYIT (Game 1) | 1:00 PM | Royce Field | Loss, 9-11 |
| Apr. 7, 2012 | SUNYIT (Game 2) | 3:30 PM | Royce Field | Loss, 4-15 |
| Apr. 9, 2012 | Cazenovia College (Game 1) | 4:30 PM | DeLutis Field (Rome, N.Y.) | Loss, 2-5 |
| Apr. 9, 2012 | Cazenovia College (Game 2) | 7:00 PM | DeLutis Field (Rome, N.Y.) | Win, 9-2 |
| Apr. 11, 2012 | at Utica College (Jackie Robinson Game) | 4:00 PM | Utica, N.Y. | Loss, 6-7 |
| Apr. 13, 2012 | Middlebury¹ | 4:00 PM | Royce Field | Win, 5-3 |
| Apr. 14, 2012 | Middlebury (Game 1)¹ | 12:00 PM | Royce Field | Loss, 2-12 |
| Apr. 14, 2012 | Middlebury (Game 2)¹ | 2:30 PM | Royce Field | Win, 5-4 |
| Apr. 20, 2012 | Wesleyan¹ | 4:00 PM | Royce Field | Loss, 2-7 |
| Apr. 21, 2012 | Wesleyan (Game 1)¹ | 9:30 AM | Royce Field | Loss, 5-8 |
| Apr. 21, 2012 | Wesleyan (Game 2)¹ | 12:00 PM | Royce Field | Loss, 1-13 |
| Apr. 28, 2012 | at Williams (Game 1)¹ | 1:00 PM | Williamstown, Mass. | Loss, 0-8 |
| Apr. 28, 2012 | at Williams (Game 2)¹ | 3:30 PM | Williamstown, Mass. | Loss, 2-11 |
| Apr. 29, 2012 | at Williams¹ | 1:00 PM | Williamstown, Mass. | Loss, 4-6 |
Home games in bold
¹ indicates NESCAC competition
