The Continentals opened 2012 with five straight victories, including three against NESCAC competition. Hamilton eventually finished the season with an overall record of 9-5-1 and was fifth in the conference standings with a 5-4-1 mark. The Continentals dropped a heartbreaker at Bowdoin College in the NESCAC championship quarterfinals by the score of 3-2. Two-time all-region selection Alex Rimmer '13 graduated as the program's all-time leading goal scorer with 37.
In their first year in the NESCAC, the Continentals either won or tied half of their 10 conference games and earned the sixth seed for the 2011 NESCAC Championship. The Continentals played No. 3 seed Williams College to a 1-1 draw in the quarterfinals, but the host Ephs advanced to the next round on penalty kicks. Hamilton blanked Middlebury College 1-0 on Oct. 8, and Middlebury went on to reach the third round of the NCAA championship.
The Continentals capped 2010 with the third NCAA championship appearance in team history. Hamilton, which finished the year with a record of 10-4-3, shut out Virginia Wesleyan 1-0 in the first round before the Continentals lost to host Johns Hopkins University in the second round. Hamilton has a winning overall record in 30-plus years of women's soccer, and the Continentals have averaged more than nine victories per season in Gilligan's 12 years.
Hamilton wrapped up its 16-year association with the Liberty League in 2010 by playing in the four-team league championship for the eighth time in nine years. Hamilton advanced to the championship game three times, including 2004, when the Continentals hosted the event and came from behind to dramatically edge William Smith College in double overtime. Hamilton claimed one league championship (2004) and two regular season titles (2004, 2007).
The Continentals enjoyed one of the finest seasons in program history in 2007 when they posted their first unbeaten regular season with a record of 13-0-1. Hamilton went on to reach the quarterfinals of the NCAA championship for the first time. After the season was finished, the team had set program records for most wins (16) and most goals (55), and was ranked first in the nation with a save percentage of .917. The team's record was 16-2-2, which was good enough for No. 7 in the final Top 25 coaches poll. The ranking was the highest in program history.
November 2007 brought two of the most thrilling athletic moments to The Hill. The first one occurred at Love Field, where the Continentals played Tufts University to a 2-2 tie through 110 minutes in the second round of the NCAA championship. Hamilton advanced to the next round due to a 4-3 edge in penalty kicks. The next hurdle was an undefeated Williams team on its home field. Undaunted, the Continentals grabbed a 2-0 lead early in the second half and hung on for one of the school's biggest victories in any sport.
A bevy of individual awards followed that season's success. Megan Brousseau '08 led a defense that allowed just 12 goals and recorded 10 shutouts in 20 games. She joined goalkeeper Jen Munoz '04 as the only All-Americans in program history. Brousseau was voted to the second team. Gilligan was selected the New York Region's coach of the year and, along with assistants Patty Kloidt and Amanda Nobis, was named the league's coaching staff of the year for the third time. Three players made the all-region team and eight received all-league honors.
2004 was the season that put the program on the Division III women's soccer map. Hamilton finished 15-2-1, captured its first league regular season and tournament titles, made its first NCAA appearance and claimed its first tournament victory. The Continentals also found themselves nationally ranked for the first time as they climbed as high as a tie for No. 8.
Women's soccer has made a total of 16 postseason appearances, including six straight in the league championship from 2002 to 2007. The Continentals have won 10 or more games in a season six times. Munoz was a first team All-America selection after 2003 when she posted a program-record nine shutouts. She boasted a 0.51 goals against average along with a .900 save percentage as Hamilton went 9-3-3.
Academics is an important piece of the women's soccer program. Kendra Wulczyn '10 was elected to the Epsilon chapter of Phi Beta Kappa, which is the nation's oldest honor society, in 2010. Erica Dressler '09, who graduated in second place on the program's career goals (34) and points (81) lists, earned two impressive academic awards in 2008. Dressler was voted to the Academic All-America Women's Soccer Team by the College Sports Information Directors of America and made the NSCAA/adidas Collegiate Scholar All-America Team. Twelve student-athletes earned 2013 NESCAC Fall All-Academic Team honors.