Defending national Champion Williams College opened the scoring at Mason Field on a goal by Seth Bair just 1:09 into the game. The Ephs increased their lead to 2-0 on a goal by Jonathan Ilgen. Hamilton then scored with 20:23 remaining in the half on a goal by Brendan Forrest, assisted by Teddy Comerford, bringing the Continentals within one of Williams at the half. However, Williams secured its victory with two unanswered goals in the second half. The first, just five minutes into the half, was scored by Robin Kelsoglu and the second, in the final minutes, was scored by Chris Smith.

Hamilton (1-1): Brendan Forrest (1-0), Teddy Comerford (0-1), Mike Heffernan 3 saves.

Williams (1-0-1): Seth Bair (1-0), Jonathan Ilgen (1-0), Robin Kelsoglu (1-0), Chris Smith (1-0), Brian Greenfield (0-1), Stephen Danbusky (0-1), Eric Watson 1 save.