Hamilton 1 Elmira 1 2 OT
November 5, 1996
Kyle Bidelspacher scored with 7:56 remaining to tie the game at one, spoiling Hamilton's bid for a shutout victory in its final game of the season. Bidelspacher's low blast just cleared the outstretched arms of Continental goalie Brian Barker (Camden). Hamilton had taken a 1-0 lead with 34:49 remaining as Ryan Stoddard headed in a cross from Jason Kingsbury (Fayetteville). In the extra sessions, Barker made made several outstanding saves before the game was called because of darkness with 1:40 remaining in the second overtime.