Professor of Philosophy Robert Simon published an op-ed on steroid use by pro athletes in the Philadelphia Inquirer (3/20/05). In "Drug-free sport is an ideal worth preserving," Simon wrote, "When I raise the issue of performance-enhancing drugs in sports to my classes on ethics, students almost unanimously condemn their use. Recent allegations of steroid use in major league baseball are especially troublesome to many students. I suspect the unwillingness of players such as Jason Giambi, Rafael Palmeiro and Frank Thomas (and initially Commissioner Bud Selig) to testify before a congressional committee will exacerbate their concerns. But when I ask them to explain why the use of such drugs is wrong, their reasons
quickly come under critical question.
"Of course, if the rules prohibit the use of performance-enhancing drugs, then those athletes who secretly violate the rules are cheating. Fairness demands that everyone play by the same rules. The real issue, however, is whether rules should prohibit the use of performance-enhancing drugs. Are there good reasons for prohibition, or is the widespread condemnation of the use of enhancers such as anabolic steroids the expression of a widespread but ultimately arbitrary prejudice?"
Simon is the author of Fair Play, about sports and social values; and a former coach of the Hamilton men's varsity golf team.
To read the entire op-ed, visit www.philly.com, where you must register and create a free account.
